Exterior of Wimbledon Magistrates and Youth Couts
Wimbledon Magistrates and Youth Courts


If, following one of your road traffic incident reports (see Reporting Incidents to the Metropolitan Police), a driver pleads not guilty after receiving a Notice of Intended Prosecution, the matter will go the magistrates court. You be advised of this possibility typically about six months after the actual incident and asked for any dates in the next six months when you might not be available. You will probably receive notice of a court date two or three months in advance. Most traffic cases in our region are heard at Lavender Hill Magistrates Court though some are heard at others including Wimbledon, Croydon, Harlesden and Ealing magistrates courts (but not at Richmond Magistrates Court, which closed in 2016). Even with a court date set, it is still possible that the CPS may, at a late stage or even on the day, decide not to proceed. It is also possible that the defendant may change their plea to guilty in which case no hearing will be necessary.

ARRIVAL

Pass through security and make it clear at reception you are a CPS witness. This can be surprisingly difficult but once done someone will fetch the relevant CPS solicitor or, more likely, you will be ushered to the witness room. This is in a secure area for CPS witnesses; everyone else has to wait to be called in the main waiting area. Ask for the code for the toilet if necessary. At some point the CPS solicitor will show up and ask if you have given evidence before. If you have not, they will talk you through the basics. However, they are not allowed to discuss your evidence with you. They will probably give you a copy of your statement. Ask for an expenses form and envelope; they are expected to provide this to you. Permitted expenses are very limited. Wait in the witness room (you may be the only occupant) to be called. My longest wait was over three hours but usually it is less than that. Take something to eat and drink, and have something to read. You may be glad you asked for the code for the toilet.

The former Richmond Magistrates Court
Richmond Magistrates Court… no longer

 

WHAT TO WEAR

You must be dressed at all times. Beyond that, opinions vary but my simple tip is do not wear anything that distracts from your evidence and definitely nothing with food on it. For the record, I’ve only seen one defendant wearing a tie. Usually the only people ‘smartly dressed’ are the solicitors, the ushers, and to a lesser extent the magistrates.

IN THE WITNESS BOX

The case will begin without you. When the court is ready, an usher will fetch you from the witness room. Once in the witness box, you take the oath, swearing or affirming, by repeating it line by line after the usher. You will be questioned first by the CPS solicitor then by the defendant or their representative. The former may begin by asking the magistrates for permission for you read from your statement. You do not have to read from your statement and probably will not need to but it is wise to have this as an option.

Speak clearly and slowly (the magistrates will be making notes) and address your answers to the magistrates. To remember to do this, stand with your toes pointing towards them. I was advised to do this by a CPS solicitor; strangely, it works.

You may well feel nervous. The court knows this and will likely be sympathetic if you stumble over your words. Remember you are not on trial and simply there to describe the incident, helping the court understand what took place. The defendant is probably a lot more nervous than you.

I was disconcerted on my first appearance by the magistrates smiling at me. On my second I was disconcerted by the magistrates not smiling at me. In short, every case is different.

Keep your answers simple and accurate (and truthful, obviously), do not elaborate unless necessary. It is the CPS’s job to make a case against the defendant, not yours. If you do not fully understand a question, say so rather than assuming the meaning and giving a potentially misleading answer.

At some point your footage will be screened and you may be asked to talk through it. If in the course of the footage you are shown, for example, ignoring a red light, cycling illegally on a footway or across a zebra crossing, this will likely be seized upon by the defendant’s solicitor to damage your credibility. That small minority of cyclists who are not always law abiding, take note.

Finally, the magistrates may have some questions but usually they do not. Once done you may then leave or sit at the back of the court to watch the rest of the case. At this point I usually go home though I was once asked, needlessly as it turned out, by the CPS solicitor to stay in case I was needed again. The proceedings can drag on for some time until eventually the magistrates retire to consider their verdict.

THE VERDICT

Traffic law can be vague and however unpleasant your experience on the road may have been, the magistrates must be satisfied that the letter of the law has been broken before they can find the defendant guilty. In a close passing case for example, it must be proven that the driver ‘inconvenienced’ the cyclist. If they are in any doubt, the magistrates have to dismiss the case. Assuming you do not stick around for the verdict, you can find the verdict by emailing or phoning the address on the email sent to you with the court date.

If the case is dismissed, do not be put off reporting incidents. In my experience only around 2% of reports reach court and each appearance by yourself is a learning process, if only learning to remember to get the code for the toilet and an expenses form. As for the driver, the case may have been dismissed but they may have spent a considerable sum on legal fees and will hopefully drive with more consideration for other road users in future.